Calling all StageSiders! Welcome back to another review here at StageSide UK. This time around, we headed to Northern Stage for the lastest show on the menu by A Play, A Pie and A Pint, Making Way.
Disclaimer: we were gifted a pair of free tickets in exchange for an honest review of the show.

One of the great strengths of A Play, A Pie and A Pint is that it offers audiences the chance to experience new writing in an informal, welcoming environment. With your ticket including lunch and a drink alongside a performance, it’s hard to argue with the concept. Unfortunately, while Making Way presented an intriguing story, it never quite delivered the theatrical experience I was hoping for.
The evening began by exchanging your drinks token at the bar before collecting your pie on the way into the auditorium. On this visit, meat-eaters could choose a chicken and mushroom pie, vegetarians were served a chickpea and spinach pie, while the vegan option was mushroom bourguignon. The pie itself was excellent and easily one of the highlights of the experience.
The theatre space was arranged with several round tables draped in black cloth positioned close to the stage, alongside a large breakfast-bar style seating area at the rear. Seating is unreserved, which creates a relaxed atmosphere and allows patrons to choose where they feel most comfortable. However, I did notice some groups becoming separated, and latecomers appeared to struggle finding available seats due to the table layout.

Once everyone had finished eating, the performance began.
What followed felt less of a play and more like an extended character monologue. That’s not inherently a problem, but it wasn’t what I had expected from the title or format. The central story was genuinely engaging, and there was enough intrigue to keep me listening throughout. In fact, I’d happily read it as a novel. My difficulty was that I wanted to see the story unfold through scenes and interactions rather than simply hear it recounted.
The staging was exceptionally minimal. Two chairs and a small scenic element suggested the character’s changing locations, placing the burden of world-building almost entirely on the audience’s imagination. Now, don’t get me wrong, much of the time I appreciate a minimalist set. However, because there was so little else going on, it felt a bit flat. The sound design was equally sparse and, when used, often felt disconnected from the action rather than integrated into the storytelling. Effects occasionally sounded more like cues being triggered from a soundboard than part of a cohesive soundscape, and the sudden songs meant to evoke nostalgia felt more abrupt.
While the performance itself was perfectly competent, I never felt fully immersed. One of my favourite aspects of theatre is being transported somewhere else for a couple of hours, and Making Way never quite managed that for me. Instead, it was the sort of small-scale production better suited to a pub venue during the Edinburgh Fringe: earnest, intimate and clearly appealing to many audience members, but not a show that completely connected with me.
I also suspect I wasn’t the intended audience. A number of the jokes were aimed at an older demographic, with several references and punchlines sailing over my head. Judging by the reactions around me, others were connecting with them far more than I was.
Overall, Making Way tells an interesting story and is supported by the consistently excellent hospitality that has become synonymous with A Play, A Pie and A Pint. However, its monologue-driven approach, sparse staging and reliance on narration meant I admired the story more than I enjoyed the performance. Not a bad show by any means, I certainly won’t start throwing pies, it’s simply one that wasn’t for me.

Accessibility
The relaxed environment of A Play, A Pie and A Pint is one of its strengths. The informal seating and dining arrangement helps make theatre feel approachable, particularly for those who may not regularly attend performances. However, the unreserved layout may prove challenging for larger groups wishing to sit together, and late arrivals could find seat availability limited depending on how the audience has dispersed throughout the space. The show itself was also only 50minutes long, so very accessible for those who can’t manage lonnger or later shows.
Value for Money
Even though the production wasn’t ultimately for me, there’s no denying the value offered by the overall package. A new theatre production, a pie and a pint for £14-£20 represents great value, and the quality of the food only enhances that. While Making Way didn’t provide the level of theatrical immersion I personally seek, the format itself remains one of the most affordable and accessible ways to experience live theatre.

Have Your Say
Have you seen a production by A Play, A Pie and A Pint? Did the show hit the spot for you? Let me know in the comments and lets get a discussion going.
As always, please be respectful of each other’s opinions and be kind to each other.
Bullying will not be tolerated and harmful language may be removed.
Head over to the Terms and conditions page to learn more about our policies, here at StageSideUK.
Follow us on Twitter and give our page a like on Facebook.

